|
The Challenger Commission for the
32nd America's Cup ("CC") met in Valencia, 15-16
March, hosted in part by Valencia City and the Holiday
Inn Valencia. .
|
As apologies were received
from Victory Challenge (SWE), challenge Representatives
from eight of nine official Challengers were
present :
|
|
-
|
BMW Oracle (USA) -- Russell
Green ;
|
|
-
|
Piu 39 (ITA) -- Luca Devoti
(alternate for Paul Henderson) ;
|
|
-
|
Team Shosholoza (RSA) -- Salvatore
Sarno ;
|
|
-
|
Emirates Team NZ (NZL) -- James
Farmer ;
|
|
-
|
K-Challenge (FRA) -- George
Clyde ;
|
|
-
|
Luna Rossa (ITA) -- Bruno Finzi
;
|
|
-
|
Desafio Espanol (ESP) -- John
Cutler ;
|
|
-
|
Mascalzone Latino (ITA) --
Tom Weaver (and Alessandra Pandarese, as alternate
the second day).
|
Prospective challengers were invited for a portion
of the meeting dealing with general business, and
the CC were pleased to have representatives of Fresh
17 (Uwe Sasse, Marketing Director) and Sausalito Challenge
2007 (Ashley Tobin, General Counsel) in attendance.
Apologies were received from Team C7 Malaysia and
China Team/Le Defi, both of which had prior commitments
related to their AC efforts. C7 and CT/LD did, however,
forward comments on a number of agenda items, which
the CC received with appreciation along with significant
input from F17 and SC2007.
ACM CEO Michel Bonnefous, ACM COO Michel Hodara, and
ACM Director of Operations Christophe Martin were
present for a portion of the meeting on 15 March,
and ACM Regatta Director Dyer Jones joined via telephone
for part of the meeting on 16 March, as did Jury Chairman
Bryan Willis.
|
Main decisions and points
of discussion:
|
|
-
|
A proposal by ACM for the Challenger
Selection Series scoring/format was, by unanimous
decision, not accepted, and the proposal adopted
by the CC at its February meeting ("San Fran
Plan") affirmed.
A working party of John Cutler, Tom Ehman,
Bruno Finzi and Dawn Riley was appointed to
meet with ACM officials, and attempt to reconcile
differences and reach an agreement before
the 29 April 2005 final challenge deadline.
|
|
-
|
A number of prospective challengers
requested that the CC seek an amendment to
the Protocol to postpone the final challenge
deadline (29 April 2005) to a date later.
This was not supported.
|
|
-
|
A draft Act 4
Notice of Race, previously negotiated by the
Chairman with Dyer Jones and Brad Butterworth
(Alinghi) following guidance from the CC at
their February meeting, was reviewed and supported
with minor modifications ;
|
|
-
|
A proposal by
the Defender to relax the 18th Crew rule,
to allow persons with acknowledged technical
or tactical skill to race as 18th Crew, was
not supported ;
|
|
-
|
It was unanimously
agreed that onboard cameramen for the 2005
Acts should be permitted (as they were in
2004) ;
|
|
-
|
It was agreed
that, during the 2005 Acts, V4 masts should
be allowed to be used in the event a team's
(only) V5 mast fails ;
|
|
-
|
A proposal from
the Regatta Director to add, for Acts 10 and
12 (Valencia 2006), knock-out semifinals and
finals for the top four boats at the end of
round-robin racing was supported ;
|
|
-
|
la demande adressée
à ACM de transmettre un plan modifié de la
Dàrsena Interior (avec un quai des superyacht
repensé) ;
|
|
-
|
a proposal for
a fleet racing series in 2007 during the Louis
Vuitton Cup semis and finals (for all Challengers
that do not advance to the semifinals), was
generally supported ;
|
|
-
|
the Chairman
reported on behalf of the Challenger of Record
that the ISAF Review Board had received an
application from Russell Coutts concerning
Protocol Article 13.12, that the Review Board
had forwarded the application to the Defender
(SNG), the Challenger of Record (GGYC) and
ACM asking for a response prior to 21 March,
and that a letter has been sent by those three
parties back to ISAF drawing their attention
to the ISAF-ACM Agreement signed in November,
2003.
Under that Agreement the ISAF Review Board
has no jurisdiction over the America's Cup.
It was also noted that the Agreement states
that the America's Cup can adopt, or decline
to adopt, any ISAF Rule or Regulation; and
that in the case of conflict between ISAF
and AC rules or regulations, the AC rules/regulations
prevail.
The CC received the report and agreed no action
was required or appropriate on the part of
the CC ;
|
|
-
|
The CC continues
to strongly oppose, for technical and fairness
reasons as well as the enormous expense, the
Met Data Service program as currently spec'd
by ACM ;
|
|
-
|
The CC asked
ACM to forward to all teams the latest site
plan for the Super Yacht Pier now under construction
in the America's Cup Harbour ;
|
|
-
|
A proposal from
ACM to "update" the Cup logo on the mainsails
was referred to the teams' marketing and legal
departments. It will be considered further
with the Defender ;
|
|
-
|
la demande adressée
à ACM de transmettre un plan modifié de la
Dàrsena Interior (avec un quai des superyacht
repensé) ;
|
|
-
|
différents désaccords
tenant aux droits TV, au marketing et aux
autres aspects commerciaux de la compétition.
|
The CC will next meet in Valencia
on 10-11 May, and again in Valencia just prior to
Act 4 on 12-13 June. A meeting to debrief Act 4
was also scheduled, to take place at 16:00 on Monday,
27 June, also in Valencia.
|